Who are the "penultimate" those just above the very bottom today?
Who are the "penultimate"—those just above the very bottom—today? They are the factory workers, the precarious laborers, the working poor. They are people who were once at the very bottom of the social ladder, but who have now been led to believe that there is someone even further down—immigrants, the new "last"—whom they can look down upon.
This mechanism has shattered something fundamental, which John Steinbeck described so magnificently in *The Grapes of Wrath*. In the novel, destitution did not isolate people; rather, it forged a shared consciousness. There is a powerful line, spoken by Ma Joad: "If you’re in trouble, or hurt, or in need—go to the poor people. They’re the only ones who’ll help—the only ones."
Today, those in power have destroyed that very awareness of a common bond. Those living in precarious conditions no longer recognize their own reflection in others who share that same reality; instead, they are often goaded into viewing those others as enemies or competitors. The sense of solidarity that once arose from the feeling of sharing a common destiny has been lost. As long as the "penultimate" continue to wage war against the "last," those at the very top can rest easy. (Giovanni D'Agata presidente dello Sportello dei Diritti)
By: